Arby’s Sauces Ranked 2024: Ingredients, Pairings & Recipes

Although Arby’s is famous for its good sandwiches, what really differentiates the chain from others in the industry is its many, variously specialized Arby’s Sauces. It’s everything from Classic Horsey Sauce to their spicy Arby’s Sauce that elevates flavor in each bite. In this unique article, we will review Arby’s Sauces, its components, and its flavor, along with the best menu items to pair them with.

Arby’s Sauces

Ingredients: Arby’s Sauces are made with a blend of sweet and sour. This blend is zested with tomato paste, vinegar, corn syrup, and allspice. That being said, the sauce is just the base in which all those ingredients mold to their perfect harmony of tang and sweet flavor.

Flavor: Perfectly complementing and bringing out Arby’s sandwiches and their just-right, bold taste with its sweet and spicy flavor. Yes, it’s tomato-based, so it will taste slightly like ketchup, but actually, it is way richer and more complex.

Perfect Pairings:

• Classic Roast Beef Sandwich: The rich, appealing roast beef pairs really well with the sour Arby’s Sauce, which rushes with flavor with every mouthful.
• Curly Fries: This Sauce offers your curly fries a lovely turn that goes well with the crispy, seasoned potatoes. It has the sweet and tangy flavor of Arby’s Sauce.
• Turkey and Swiss Sandwich: The Sauce’s sharpness and sourness cut through the milder flavors of the cheese and turkey to create a more strong, well-balanced flavor.

Arby’s Horsey Sauce

Ingredients: Arby’s Horsey Sauces basically contain mayonnaise, horseradish, and a few other ingredients. No surprise here; the strong flavor of horseradish obviously leads the charge.

Flavor: The flavor profile of Arby’s Horsey Sauces is rich and creamy with a hard hitter of horseradish, well-balanced to the heat to improve the flavors without overpowering them.

Perfect Pairings:

• Beef ‘n Cheddar Sandwich: The Horseradish warms up the Arby’s Horsey Sauce so that it gives a bold flavor that doesn’t get lost to the beef and sharp cheddar.
• Arby’s Melt: For a nice spicy, creamy effort to top off that melted cheese and roast beef, take a dip in some Horsey Sauce with an Arby’s Melt.
• French Dip & Swiss: It’s Arby’s Horsey Sauce that makes the au jus and roast beef pop on the French Dip & Swiss. So, this addition adds a new level of taste and heat.

Three Pepper Sauce

Ingredients: In making a sauce highly flavored and a little hot, the mixing of chili peppers, vinegar, garlic, and sugar makes Three Pepper Sauce.

Flavor Profile: These Arby’s sauces have a kick with the chili peppers, but they are mildly sweet and spicy. Even for people who are intolerant of heat, the sweetness from the sugar subdues the heat, making it extremely palatable.

Perfect Pairings:

• Smokehouse Brisket Sandwich: The smokey flavors of the Three Pepper Arby’s Sauce accentuate the sweet heat of the brisket, leaving your mouth watering.
• Jalapeño Bites: A spicy and tasty snack, especially when paired with Three Pepper Arby’s Sauce.
• Loaded Italian Sandwich: All the layers, from meats to cheeses, are properly paired and lifted in taste when the Sauce adds its zesty and spicy note—a break in the richness with its tangy and peppery flavor.

Spicy Buffalo Sauce

Ingredients: Butter, spicy Sauce, and a mixture of blended spices make up Arby’s Spicy Buffalo Sauce. Its spice comes from the spicy Sauce, and its richness and creaminess come from the butter.

Flavor Profile: Arby’s sauces have a buttery touch that balances out the heat just enough to make them palatable despite being strong and spicy. It’s a traditional Buffalo sauce with a strong flavor that doesn’t overpower.

Perfect Pairings:

• Chicken Tenders: The succulent, crunchy chicken pieces blend seamlessly with the fiery Buffalo Arby’s Sauce, producing a gratifying and fiery taste each time. It is in the top tier of Arby’s dipping sauces because it has a rather bold and fiery flavor that pairs perfectly with tenders.
• Buffalo Chicken Slider: Finish with a drizzle of Spicy Buffalo Arby’s Sauce for an extra kick to every bite.
• Roast Turkey Ranch & Bacon Sandwich: The sandwich gains depth from the Buffalo sauce’s hot kick, which contrasts well with the chilled ranch and savory bacon.

Tangy Barbeque Sauce

Ingredients: This Arby’s Sauce is made with lots of sweetening up, such as tomato paste, brown sugar, vinegar, and other spices. It’s your classic BBQ sauce with a zip that’s a bit different.

Flavor Profile: Sweet and tangy with a tomato base, these Arby’s sauces are a bit rich and a tad smoky. Brown sugar is what really brings flavor into this, adding just a touch of sweetness. It’s the vinegar that gives it a tang, giving sharpness to the flavor of barbecue.

Perfect Pairings:

• Smokehouse Brisket Sandwich: The smoky taste of the brisket is balanced out with the sweet and tangy of Arby’s Sauce—each one bringing out the flavor of the overall sandwich.
• Crispy Fish Sandwich: Put some of the sweet and smoky— it mellows the light fish—over the top of a Crispy Fish Sandwich with Tangy Barbeque Arby’s Sauce.
• Chicken Bacon Swiss Sandwich: The saltiness of the chicken and bacon is balanced with the BBQ sauce at Arby’s, and it has a shine of sweetness mixed in there, which makes one heck of a flavor combination.

Honey Mustard Sauce

Ingredients: Honey Mustard Arby’s Sauce An extremely simple mixture of mustard, honey, vinegar, and a plus—added flavor. The mustard makes it spicy-sour while the honey makes it sweet.

Flavor Profile: These Arby’s sauces come smooth in texture and sweet with acidic notes. The honey counterbalances the sharpness of the mustard, making it mild yet flavorsome for many palates.

Perfect Pairings:

• Chicken Tenders: A traditional combination for chicken tenders, the sweet and tangy Honey Mustard Arby’s Sauce gives each bite a flavorful explosion.
• Turkey Club Sandwich: The savory turkey and bacon pair well with the Sauce’s subtle sweetness, creating a more delicious sandwich.
• Crispy Chicken Sandwich: Silky chicken counterbalances the crunch with a tangy, sweet twist from the Honey Mustard Arby’s Sauce.

Dijon Honey Mustard Sauce

Ingredients: Honey Mustard Dijon Arby’s Sauce The ingredients include Dijon mustard, honey, vinegar, and a mix of spices. Dijon mustard is much more involved and balanced than plain honey mustard.

Flavor Profile: The honey gives the perception of sweetness to this tart and mildly spicy Arby sauce. The dimension of flavor that Dijon mustard brings keeps this Sauce full-bodied and sophisticated.

Perfect Pairs:

• Roast Beef Sandwich: This Dijon Honey Mustard Arby’s Sauce serves boldly with a taste similar to the savory and rich roast beef, bringing freshness and elevating the flavor profile.
• Grilled Chicken Sandwich: The sauce details give a different dimension of flavor and fullness to the grilled chicken.
• Ham & Swiss Sandwich: The ham and the Swiss really come together with the Dijon Honey Mustard Arby’s Sauce to bring out the cheese and the meat for a good, balanced sandwich.

Cheddar Cheese Sauce

Ingredients: Cheddar Cheese Arby’s Sauce contains melted cheddar cheese, milk, and additional seasonings. It’s creamy and rich in flavor, full of cheese.

Flavor: If one had to describe the flavor profile of these Arby’s sauces, they would be rich, flavorful, creamy, and cheesy.. Tastes robust for cheddar cheese. That is what makes it so dear to cheese lovers.

Perfect Pairs:

• Beef ‘n Cheddar Sandwich: This sandwich is great because the Cheddar Cheese Arby’s Sauce brackens the roast beef with a rich, cheesy layer that goes well with it.
• Arby’s Fries: For that delicious and flavorful snack that you would harden and never turn down, ask to drizzle your fries with Cheddar Cheese Arby’s Sauce.
• Loaded Curly Fries: Curly fries will be given that rich, flavored cheesy treat with the Cheddar Cheese Arby’s Sauce.

Marinara Sauce

Ingredients: Tomatoes, garlic, onions, and a mix of Italian herbs and spices make up Arby’s Marinara Sauce. Rich and savory, it’s a typical marinara.

Flavor Profile: The tomatoey, rich Arby’s sauces have a faint sense of sweetness and a tinge of herb flavor. It is a tasty addition to any dish since the onions and garlic give it depth.

Perfect Pairs:

• Mozzarella Sticks: A classic pairing with mozzarella sticks is the Marinara Arby’s Sauce that dips these cheesy sticks in a full, tangy flavor.
• Italian Sub: Pair an Italian sub with Marinara Arby’s Sauce for the ultimate salty collaboration that really raises the flavor profile of this sandwich.
• Meatball Sandwich: The flavor of the meatballs and the richness of the tomatoey flavor in Marinara Arby’s Sauce blend together to offer a tasteful and filling sandwich.

Garlic Aioli

Ingredients: Aioli includes garlic mayonnaise, garlic, lemon juice, and a mix of seasonings. The lemon juice improves the flavor, while the garlic adds body.

Flavor Profile: The creamy, garlicky Arby’s sauces have a hint of tang from lemon juice. It is the major component—garlic—that provides the pungent, savory flavor ideal for kicking up any meal.

Perfect Pairings:

• Turkey Bacon Ranch Sandwich: A creamy, garlicky flavor from the Garlic Aioli will magnify the taste of the turkey, bacon, and ranch in the sandwich to make it more robust.
• Roast Beef Gyro: Add a creamy, garlicky condiment known as Garlic Aioli to this classic gyro to enhance the savory flavor.
• Crispy Fish Sandwich: The delicate taste of the fish provides a nice base for the garlicky aioli to create the taste bomb with every bite.

Conclusion

Knowing Arby’s Sauces takes you closer to the best mixes needed to bring out the magic in the meal, that be it the creamy richness brought by Cheddar Cheese Arby’s Sauce, the fire contained in Arby’s Horsey Sauce or yet the sweet tang of Arby’s Sauces.

At Cameo Cafe, we give you all possible insights into your fast-food experience, from menu options to happy hours. Explore our guides to learn about new taste combinations and pairings before your next trip to Arby’s. Our goal is to make sure you enjoy your favorite dishes.